/* */ /* Mailchimp integration */
-1
archive,paged,author,author-zoe,author-2,paged-6,author-paged-6,wp-theme-stockholm,wp-child-theme-stockholm-child,stockholm-core-1.0.8,select-child-theme-ver-1.1,select-theme-ver-5.1.5,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,menu-animation-underline,header_top_hide_on_mobile,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-6.0.2,vc_responsive

Should Teachers Be Allowed to Choose Their Evaluations?

By Tanya Hettler, Ph.D., Guest Contributor

A bill sponsored by Sen. Laura Sturgeon, Senate Bill 165, titled “An Act to Amend Title 14 of the Delaware Code Relating to Student Improvement Component,” has just passed in the Delaware General Assembly.

The bill requires the Delaware Department of Education to pilot a new method of teacher evaluation that allows teachers to choose how they are evaluated and considers factors that may negatively affect student performance, such as student absences, noncompliance, or a lack of parental involvement. In practice, this could allow poor test scores to be excluded entirely from a teacher’s evaluation-regardless of classroom instruction-raising concerns about accountability and transparency.

As is often the case, this bill is misleadingly framed as a “student improvement” measure when it is actually about making teacher evaluations easier and thus will not lead to student improvement. Instead of overlooking student absences and behavior problems, shouldn’t schools and teachers be working to decrease these kinds of disruptive behaviors and increase parental involvement?

Over the past four years, Delaware lawmakers have passed four Science of Reading (SoR) bills. The Science of Reading (SoR) involves direct and explicit instruction in phonics along with four other essentials that have been proven effective in teaching literacy.

The first of these bills, SB 4, passed in 2021, yet does not require SoR to be fully implemented until the 2027-2028 school year. This delay means another six years of students who have not learned to read. This is unacceptable.

States that hold students, teachers and families accountable for literacy have far better literacy scores than Delaware, which continues to obscure poor literacy results and is attempting to reduce accountability even further through SB 165.

While the rest of the country works effectively to implement SoR in their schools so students can learn to read, Delaware seems more focused on decreasing accountability and unconcerned with being among the bottom five states in the country in academic performance, according to the National Assessment of Educational Progress.

Delaware’s public school students are suffering because their teachers and schools are not being held accountable for teaching them basic reading and math. Only 41% of Delaware students can read at grade level and only 31% can do math at grade level. Delaware teachers should not have even less accountability as proposed in SB 165. In what other profession are employees allowed to choose their evaluations? None. SB 165 focuses on what makes life easier for adults in our schools rather than what is best for the children.

Delaware must immediately require teachers to be trained in the SoR and require that it be implemented to teach literacy in all districts when school starts again in September 2025. There are districts in the state that have not even begun SoR professional learning. Some superintendents do not even seem aware that a law requires SoR to be taught or that SoR is entirely backed by scientific and classroom evidence.

When it comes to evaluating teachers, we should continue to use the statewide Smarter Balanced assessment (or choose another statewide assessment) to compare student performance at the beginning and end of each grade.

Additionally, schools should be held accountable for implementing effective policies to reduce absenteeism and for improving communication with families, such as those implemented in West Seaford Elementary School, rather than ignoring these issues.

Delaware’s legislature should also reverse SB 85, a bill about student discipline, which has led to significant increases in student misbehavior and general chaos in Delaware schools, as reported in a survey conducted by the Delaware State Education Association.

SB 165 will be a disaster for Delaware’s students. The last thing that our schools need is another excuse for poor academic performance. Instead, Delaware must enforce its Science of Reading laws so that students can learn to read, and schools must implement effective strategies to reduce absenteeism and behavioral problems.

Tanya Hettler, Ph.D., is head of the Center for Education Policy at the Caesar Rodney Institute.

 

 

 

Delaware’s Progressive Policies Create An Economic Mirage*

By: Charlie Copeland, Guest Contributor

For two decades, Delaware has been a laboratory for progressive economic policy. From expanded social programs to aggressive minimum wage hikes, from increased business regulations to generous unemployment benefits, our state has faithfully implemented the liberal playbook. The results are now clear: these well-intentioned policies have created an economic mirage that appears successful on paper, while systematically excluding tens of thousands of Delawareans from productive economic participation and ultimately leading to an income tax increase.

Delaware politicians celebrate the state’s 3.6% unemployment rate and rising wages as evidence that progressive policies work. But the real story lies in what they don’t mention: our labor force participation rate has collapsed from 65.7% in 2005 to just 59.0% today. If Delaware had maintained its 2005 participation levels, our unemployment rate would actually be 10.3%.

This represents roughly 45,000 to 50,000 working-age Delawareans who have simply stopped looking for work. They haven’t disappeared—they’ve been absorbed into an expanding web of government dependency programs that progressive policymakers have steadily enlarged over the past two decades.

The wage growth story reveals the fundamental flaw in progressive economic thinking. Yes, employed workers saw 47% wage increases from 2014 to 2025, but according to the Federal Reserve, real per capita income for all Delawareans grew by only 1.4% annually, well below historical standards. Progressive policies created artificial wage floors and benefits that priced many workers out of the job market entirely, while those who remained employed benefited from an increasingly exclusive economy.

This is the expected result of progressive economic policies. When the government makes it costly to hire workers through mandates, regulations, and payroll taxes, businesses tend to hire fewer employees while paying their existing staff more. When social programs offer attractive alternatives to working, sensible people opt not to work. The outcome is exactly what we observe in Delaware: higher wages for fewer workers and a growing number of residents dependent on government support. The increase in Delawareans relying on assistance is reflected in state spending, which has risen by an average of 7.15% since 2018—nearly double the inflation rate of 3.73% during the same period.

In 2005, Delaware still maintained some of its traditional pro-business orientation. Today, after years of progressive governance, we’ve become another high-cost, high-regulation state that drives out working family jobs while creating lucrative opportunities for college-educated professionals who can navigate the regulatory maze.

The policy mechanisms are clear. Generous unemployment benefits reduce incentives to find work quickly. Expansive disability programs provide alternatives to employment. High minimum wages price out entry-level workers. Progressive housing policies have made Delaware’s housing market expensive, forcing working families to choose between unaffordable rents and government housing assistance.

A few targeted policy reforms can start reversing this damage. For example, Delaware could forgive 1% of the state’s share of the real estate transfer tax for individual home buyers—not LLCs or business entities—purchasing property in low-income census blocks. This would help working families build wealth through homeownership in areas where economic stability is most needed, while discouraging reliance on government assistance.

Charlie Copeland is the board chair of Associates International. He sits on the Board of Governor’s at the Delaware State Chamber of Commerce and serves as the chair of the Center for Economic and Fiscal Policy at the Caesar Rodney Institute.

*This article was first published in the Delaware Business Times on July 2, 2025, and is reprinted here with permission from the author.

 

 

Delaware’s Expanding Budget and the Need for Fiscal Responsibility

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

The members of the General Assembly have recently interjected the State into areas where it dared not go previously.  They voted to override county zoning decisions and municipal restrictions on certain business activities. They took over the oversight of hospital budgets, complaining about the costs the state incurs for healthcare and yet, at the same time, expanded the medical services that were covered by the state insurance plan.

Repeatedly, governors and legislators have voted to increase spending on education. In fact, at an incredible pace. Yet, despite the fact that we have enacted continued and consistent increases in spending, they have led only to a consistent and persistent decline in student performance.  Perhaps you remember the term “direct and inverse correlation” from school? We are in the top ten in terms of spending and the bottom three or four in student performance. The state should try programs that have been proven to work to elevate student performance and achievement in other states, with as challenging a history as we have established in the past 10 years. Mandate that a child must read at third grade level in order to be promoted to fourth grade.  Allow parents to more easily see how their child’s school ranks and the proficiency of the students attending by requiring the State Department of Education to make it very clear where to find it on the Department’s website. Give parents the authority to place their child in the school of their choice.

Recently the General Assembly approved a stopgap measure, a one-time allocation, to help families struggling to pay the utility bills. Well, not all of them – estimates are the funds will help about 2% of those who are currently struggling. The state’s insistence on shutting down Delaware’s capacity to generate power and to promote costly and less reliable alternative energy sources is driving, and keeping, prices higher.

Our state government could adopt policies that lower energy costs, improve student performance and allow more families to succeed without government handouts that are literally too little and too late. The legislature could eliminate laws that limit competition in healthcare, which increases costs and restricts access to quality health care.  State government is costing more than it should and all of Delaware would benefit from cost-effective and common-sense policies.

Since its inception, A Better Delaware has advocated that Delaware establish the position of Inspector General. We applaud the General Assembly for finally (after it was first proposed more than a decade ago) passing a law that establishes the Office of Inspector General. That office is designed to help identify fraud, waste, and mismanagement in state government, the agencies, the legislature and all aspects of government action.  The person who is selected must be independent, guided by only the best interest of Delawareans, and not be held hostage by political views of anyone in the General Assembly or the Governor’s Office.

Perhaps the work of the Inspector General will lead to savings, and recommendations about improvements and policies that will help save taxpayers money. Perhaps, the work of that office will bring a sense of responsibility to a state government that consistently spends our money without truly determining how, accompanied with common sense policies, it can best work to enhance the lives of Delawareans. We have high hopes and expectations of what can be – our objective everyday – A Better Delaware.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

Impact of Government Policies on Delaware Utility Costs

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

Sometimes politicians just don’t get that the tax revenue that they spend on government projects is our money. Recently, the budget for the next fiscal year was passed in the General Assembly. One of the provisions would direct $6.5 million to help pay the utility bills or provide energy efficient upgrades to residents who are not able to pay their energy bills.  Governor Meyer touted the benefit to those individuals while reportedly proclaiming that it would help those individuals “without shifting any of the cost burden onto customers “.

That $6.5 million came from somewhere, and that somewhere is from us. $6.5 million is $6.50 for every Individual who lives in Delaware, not all of whom pay taxes, but most of whom consume public utility services. While we at A Better Delaware think it is appropriate to help those who truly cannot keep the heat or air conditioning on and suffer from health or other conditions that make the situation dangerous, it is not accurate or fair to say that it’s not costing “customers “any money.

Many of us complained in January about the high cost of our utility bills. If you think you’re paying a lot for electricity, you are right, but the cost is not entirely reflected in your bill.

Legislation that has passed over the last two sessions, in particular, has increased the cost of construction of single-family and multi-family residential homes and the cost of the construction of commercial buildings, spent your tax dollars to support individuals who buy all electric or hybrid vehicles, and mandates the purchase of a certain number of electric school buses each year.

The construction of new residential homes now requires that electric vehicle charging infrastructure be included in that construction, and the General Assembly has given city and county government the authority to enforce those requirements. The cost of construction obviously is higher, which means the cost of buying a new home or condominium is higher, and the construction of an apartment building is more costly, so the rent is higher. You are paying for that infrastructure whether you have an electric vehicle or not.

The construction of commercial buildings now must include installation of a roof that is able to support solar energy infrastructure. That means that the cost of the construction of those buildings goes up, the companies either building or renting those buildings will have to pay more and the cost will be shared by you as a customer. You are paying for that infrastructure.

The cost of an all-electric or hybrid vehicle is in general, much more expensive than a gas-powered vehicle, so in a competitive market, the lower priced vehicle is favored, especially for those in a lower economic situation.  In order to provide incentives to consumers to purchase those vehicles, the government provides subsidies to those consumers. Purely at the state level (because there have been federal subsidies as well), a purchaser of an all-electric vehicle is entitled to up to $2500 toward the cost as an incentive and the purchaser of a hybrid vehicle is entitled to up to $1000. That money is coming from the state coffers. You are paying for that rebate.

We at A Better Delaware have written extensively about the intrusion of government into private businesses. It is a trend that continued in this session of the General Assembly. Legislation was passed this session that would cap or limit the amount of money that a Delmarva Power could spend on capital expenses – that is improvement of their buildings, infrastructure, transmission, trucks, and all of the attendant capital expenses required for them to do their job well. The bill further provides greater oversight in order, according to the General Assembly to “challenge unnecessary rate hikes “.

Government does not know how to run a business. Indeed, if government were a business, it would have a very poor credit rating and be unable to raise the money in a capital market that it takes from us as taxpayers to do the things it has chosen to do. For government to intrude into the future planning of infrastructure needs of a business and the capital required to both maintain and improve that infrastructure is poorly considered. Indeed, it will create an administrative quagmire and will stifle innovation.

Finally, looking forward, the General Assembly has expressed a clear preference for offshore wind power generation, and voted to override a county decision regarding zoning that would affect a particular project because they disagreed with the impact it would have on that preference.  That particular project won’t bring any energy to Delaware as a practical matter, but focusing on offshore wind as a source of energy is fraught with hazard. Offshore wind can be as much as four times as expensive as energy from coal or natural gas. It is intermittent and unreliable and must have backup sources to avoid brownouts, blackouts and breakdowns in service.  More choices and many diverse options for energy without the detrimental impact that offshore wind has on the environment are available, including nuclear and natural gas.

There are a lot of reasons why your utility bills are higher, and not all of them are evident in your bill. Delaware’s public policies are costing each one of us a great deal every month. Our leadership will choose the policies they prefer because majority does rule, but they should not pretend that the cost of those policies does not exist.  Governor Meyer, you can’t spend $6.5 million of State money and claim that it will not cost the customers anything. We are all customers of Delaware‘s government, and we are paying that bill.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

Advocating for Financial Literacy in Delaware Schools: Make Your Voice Heard!

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

It is not often that everyone in the Delaware State House of Representatives agrees, but that’s exactly what happened when House Substitute 1 for House Bill 203 was called for a vote. The bill passed 40-0. (The house has 41 members, but one member was absent).

The bill seeks to fundamentally change the systemic disparities that have existed with regard to access to financial knowledge and education. It proposes a 1/2 credit financial literacy requirement be placed in the social studies curriculum of every high school in Delaware beginning in the 2026-2027 school year

Financial literacy is no longer a luxury for the rich. Financial realities today are more complex than ever. Many households in America are living paycheck to paycheck. Some have no savings – over a third report they have no retirement savings.
Studies have shown that nearly 90% of American teens admit they don’t understand the principles and concepts of personal finance.

Delaware students deserve the opportunity to learn about disciplined savings, the impact of interest, how to manage debt effectively, how to recognize the difference between a good investment and a risky one, what taxes they are paying and the impact of taxes on their financial stability, and how to plan for a career. These are essential skills that will help them engage successfully in the 21st-century economy.

Managing your financial stability is as foundational as being able to read or do math. Some schools in Delaware have a personal finance class – some offer even more than 1/2 a credit financial education class. Every school should offer at least a 1/2 credit class.

Many people who work with those who struggle financially support this bill. The National Council on Economic Education assisted the prime sponsor, Representative Jeff Hilovsky, in writing and advocating for the bill. Supporters are reported to include a diverse group of advocates, including the Delaware Bankers Association, Junior Achievement, the Committee of 100 Black Men, the Board of Realtors and Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity.

You might ask “Why are you telling me all this? The bill passed unanimously in the House.”  That’s correct.  But recently, a few Senators key to getting this bill out of committee and onto the Senate floor for a Senate vote have held the bill up. Contact Senators Elizabeth Lockman, David Sokola and Laura Sturgeon  and tell them that you want them to allow this bill to come out of committee and onto the floor for a vote.

It is generally believed that the bill will pass with a significant margin if allowed to get to the floor. These individuals should not hold up such an important and universally supported piece of legislation. Make your voice heard. Have a role in making Delaware better. Urge your Senator to demand their colleagues release this bill and to vote YES for financial literacy.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

Senate Bill 159: A State Mandate Over Local Zoning in Delaware

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

This week, the Delaware State Senate passed Senate Bill 159, a bill to pre-empt county zoning decisions in certain specific circumstances.  Coincidentally, those circumstances coincide precisely with the facts related to the denial by
Sussex County Council of a permit for a substation associated with the US Wind offshore wind project.

The bill addresses “conditional use permits for electrical substations.”  The bill prohibits a county from denying a conditional use permit for an electrical substation if it is being proposed to support the operation of a proposed renewable energy generation project of 250 MW or greater, would be located in a heavy industrial area, an electric substation is an allowed use in the zone, and the specific zoning district already has an electric substation located in the zone. Further, it is to apply retroactively to 2023.

There are many reasons people oppose offshore wind projects – their view of the open ocean is marred, property sales and rental values are diminished, the noise, the lights that are visible at night, the adverse impact on fishing and recreation, and the terrible consequences for marine life and the environment.

But none of those reasons are why the Sussex County Council had the authority to, and properly denied, the conditional use request of US Wind.  Sussex County Council has an obligation to act for the benefit of the residents of Sussex County.  The Council determined there was no benefit to their constituents as a result of this project. Why?

First, US Wind calls this project the Maryland Project for a reason. It was started as a result of an agreement between US Wind and the Maryland government for an offshore wind farm to provide electric to Maryland citizens.  Statutes were passed, policies were adopted, and permits were sought from the federal and Maryland authorities. Problems developed when no subdivision of Maryland would permit the transmission lines from the offshore windmills to come ashore in any Maryland site.

In steps (then) Governor Carney, who agreed, per a term sheet he executed, to allow the transmission lines to come into Delaware’s Seashore State Park.  Permits were then sought to disrupt the beach, go under the Indian River Bay and through wetlands to a site where US Wind proposed to construct a substation.  That site was next to the site where the (now) closed Indian River Power Plant is located.  The Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control (DNREC) granted those permits, which are now being appealed before the Environmental Appeals Board and in the Superior Court.

US Wind, however, also needed a permit for the substation to which the transmission lines would connect.  To build that substation they needed permission for a conditional use from Sussex County.

At the hearing before the Sussex County Council, the members heard testimony that there were no jobs that would be created by this project for Sussex County citizens, except, perhaps, a few, on a temporary basis. The representative from US Wind indicated that the site was expected to be monitored remotely from a location in Maryland.  There also was no guarantee, indeed, no expectation that electricity from the project would be provided to Delaware or Sussex County citizens.  In fact, Maryland was guaranteed the expected output directly.

Further, the entirety of the environmental risk and impact fell directly on Sussex County’s valued natural resources and citizens.  The federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the National Marine and Fisheries both recommended against going under the Indian River Bay, yet DNREC permitted it. US Wind had originally proposed 4 possible routes to get the electricity generated by the windmills to the substation, only one of which proposed the dredging and disruption caused by going under the Bay. It apparently was the cheaper route, the one US Wind proposed, and the one DNREC chose to permit.

The Council also heard testimony that commercial and recreational fishing, boating and other activities will be affected, and that curtailment of those activities, as well as the sight and sound of the windmills off the coast will affect rental and sales of properties in coastal Sussex County.

The Sussex County Council properly determined that their duty and responsibility to the citizens of Sussex County and the precious natural resources under their care would not benefit from the project as planned and denied the conditional use.

The State could not be any clearer that Senate Bill 159 is intended to undo that ruling, made months ago, on a proper record and for the right reasons. The bill must still be passed by the Delaware House of Representatives to become law.  Contact your representative and let them know you oppose this bill and want them to vote NO. Whether you live in Sussex County, boat in Sussex County, visit the beaches in Sussex County, or just don’t want the State telling your local government what to do the next time they disagree with a ruling overwhelmingly favored by the local residents, you need to be heard.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

 

Towards Transparent Governance: Establishing Delaware’s Office of Inspector General

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

Since its inception, A Better Delaware has advocated for more transparency and accountability from our state government.  We have pushed for more open access to what our government does through an expanded Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and for the establishment of an Office of Inspector General.  We may be closer than ever in reaching the latter goal.

The Delaware Senate recently unanimously passed a bill creating and funding an independent and nonpartisan Office of Inspector General.  The office is charged with the authority to investigate fraud, waste and corruption in Delaware government, coordinate with law enforcement agencies and refer matters for prosecution when appropriate.  This bill, and others like it intending to accomplish the same result, have been the discussion of legislative sessions for over a decade. It is time to move forward with opening the window on abuse and waste of taxpayer funds and the abuse of power by those in authority.  The Delaware House of Representatives will take the bill up shortly. Contact your Representative and let them know you support SB4 and better oversight of Delaware government.

The bill would then go to the Governor for signature.  Governor Matt Meyer supported the idea and purpose of an Inspector General in his campaign for office last year.  He even referenced it in his State of the State address following his election as Governor. But, when he submitted a substitute budget for that which his predecessor, John Carney has proposed, he did not include funding for the Office of Inspector General.  Whatever the reasons for not including support for the office in his proposed budget, Governor Meyer should encourage the House to pass this legislation and should sign this bill when it comes to his desk.  There is every reason to support open and transparent government, elimination of waste and fraud and to curb the abuse of power.  Additionally, if his concern was financial resources, DEFAC, the agency that reviews receipts and expenditures and advises how much money the state has available for expenditures, recently increased their projection by nearly $100 million.  There is certainly enough money to fund the office, which, if what many expect is true, will ultimately pay for itself with the exposure of fraud and waste of taxpayer funds.

Let both Governor Meyer know you what him to stand up for this effort and encourage the House of Representatives to act swiftly and favorably on this bill and to commit to sign it when it reaches his desk. And, contact your Representative and let them know that you support Senate Bill 4, and want them to vote YES on Senate Bill 4.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

Delaware’s Housing Sector: Factors Affecting Affordability and Availability

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

Delaware has a housing shortage. Why, you ask, when it seems like every time you turn around, there is a new development?!

In large part, it is the cost.  According to data from the Federal Reserve, in 1984, the median sale price of a home was 3.5 times median income; now it is 5.8 times.  In order to buy a median priced home today, a buyer would need to earn over $100,000 per year.  According to the US Census Bureau, the median income for Delaware is $82, 855. Housing is simply priced out of the market for many.

There are several reasons for the high cost. The bottom line is that there is very low inventory. There are not enough houses for sale to meet the demand buyers are placing on the market.  In the law of supply and demand, which pushes the price of housing up.

Low interest rates is a big part of the picture. After the housing crash in 2008, there was a prolonged period with low interest rates that made the long-term costs of home ownership less expensive.  Increased demand pushed the price of homes higher. Now, those buyers are facing higher interest rates and, even if they want to move, are staying put because they do not want the added interest burden.

Additionally, Delaware’s transfer tax is the highest in the nation.   That tax, on a home sold for $384, 079, is over $15,000, and is usually split between the buyer and seller.  That is a lot of money.

Further, a new generation, millennials are entering the housing market, pushing demand, and therefore, prices, higher. And, finally, there has been a huge increase in large investors buying properties and turning them into rental units, taking them out of the housing market.

Another aspect of inventory that affects prices is not just how many units are available for sale, but what kind of units they are.  Inventory needs to be diverse, including condo, townhome and single-family units.  And the best and most competitive markets are always moving.  Delaware’s housing market is not robust, but rather stagnant at the moment.

Many people moved to Delaware, particularly, but not exclusively, Sussex County, during the pandemic. New York and New Jersey residents could now work remotely and live in a more tax-friendly state with lower housing costs. That pushed to cost of housing up, significantly in some areas.

What are some of the consequences of an expensive housing market? Well, consumer spending on other items, including essentials, is curtailed.  Fewer families can afford to eat out, take vacation, visit a water park or the beach for a weekend.

Our economic freedom is affected.  People may not move to take a better job because they can’t afford housing in a new location. According to Visual Capitalist, there are severe shortages of workers in many cities because lower wage workers cannot afford to live in those cities, affecting market efficiency and productivity growth.

The costs of construction and the expense that regulations and restrictions add to those costs also factor into the cost of buying a home.  According to the National Association of Home Builders, government regulation overall accounts for about 24 percent of the final price of a new, single-family home, and it is more than 40% for a multi-family development.

And it is not just home sales that have been affected. Rental costs are very high as well.  Only 39% of renters in the U.S. are earning enough to afford a median-priced apartment. That doesn’t mean they’re not still renting—just that their rent consumes more than 30% of their income,

According to the US Department of the Treasury, from 2000 to 2020, median rents rose faster than median household income in 88 percent of U.S. counties. There may be some relief soon, however. According to Sheharyar Bokhari, Redfin Senior Economist, “Rents are growing at a snail’s pace compared to the rapid increases we saw during the pandemic and are unlikely to soar again anytime soon. As a result, wage growth should continue to outpace rent growth in the coming months, as it has been doing since 2022. That will help narrow the affordability gap for renters.”

Recently, there has been discussion in the Delaware General Assembly about introducing rent control legislation to address the increase in rent.  However, research has consistently shown that rent controls are counterproductive. Rather than increase the number of rental units available and keeping costs down, rental inventory typically declines, neighborhoods become static, and ultimately, renting becomes less, rather than more, affordable.

According to economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, “Rent-control policies can have other downsides beyond dampening the growth of rental housing stock. Several economists found negative effects on housing quality; their studies show rent-controlled buildings or areas with large concentrations of rent-controlled units tend to have more dilapidated units, suggesting that rent control reduces landlords’ incentives to maintain their units.”

Delaware should adopt policies that increase the availability of affordable housing. Those policies include reducing regulation and costs of construction, reducing the transfer tax on the sale of homes, and avoiding intrusion into the free market with regard to rent, by declining to adopt any rent control measures.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

Addressing Delaware’s Housing Challenges: A Look at Legislation and Market Dynamics

 By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

Delaware is estimated to have approximately 20,000 fewer housing units than the demand requires.  That often means that there is a shortage of affordable housing, creating a stagnant market and homelessness.

There are a number of issues that have affected the “inventory” of housing in Delaware. One has been the incredibly low mortgage rates for the past few years. Homeowners are reluctant to sell because they will have to pay higher rates for their new purchase. Second, there is not sufficient diversity of the housing units available for purchase. Some people see their dream in a single-family home, others in a condo or townhome, and still others in a rental of any one of the above.   We lack that diversity in sufficient numbers to meet demand.

And the costs are high.  According to Bankrate, which has a calculator to determine how much home you can afford, if you make $80,000 a year and put down $20,000 on a house, the best affordability is a $283,000 home. The maximum that you should attempt to purchase is $353,000. The median price for a single-family home in Delaware, according to Bankrate is $396,000, more than about half the states.   The Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University found that, in 2022 the median price of a single-family home was 5.6 times the median household income. That’s higher than any other point in their records.  Prior to the pandemic. It was 4.1 times median income. The recommended rate, according to the Center, is 2.6. Low interest rates for an extended period and limited inventory produced higher prices, and wages were not keeping pace. Fanny Mae home purchase sentiment index indicates that 77% of consumers surveyed believe now is a bad time to buy a home.

According to marketplace.org from 1984 to 2023 the median cost of a new home rose at double the rate of the overall price inflation.  And, according to Cotality’s Chief Economist Selma Hepp, home price growth is expected to continue, and it is “especially apparent in the Northeast and Midwest, where the severe lack of inventory is helping prop up home prices.”

Housing construction costs are high as well, and the regulations regarding what needs to be included in the construction of building structures are ever increasing, including infrastructure costs, climate accommodation and material requirements.  There is an inherent bias in most buyers against density (apartments multi-story, multi-unit structures, etc.) because of traffic and infrastructure demands, and there is an inherent bias in most laws and regulations toward density.

So, what is the General Assembly doing to address this issue? Well, recent legislation would permit the construction of additional dwelling units (ADUs) to be added to current housing structures or property. Picture an in-law suite, but it does not have to be connected to the existing house.  Little public comment has been made on this issue at this point but look for objections to any entirely independent structures.

Most of the General Assembly’s effort has been directed at rentals.  One bill, SB150, would create a fund to provide loans to very low-, low-, and moderate-incomes, the elderly and individuals with disabilities.   But several other efforts are misguided and will be counterproductive.

HB 455 establishes rent controls, requires the Delaware State Housing Authority (DSHA) to calculate a fair market rent (FMR) and determine consumer price index, urban (CPI-U) for each county, and requiring landlords to report to the DSHA specific data regarding all their rental units.  Rent controls have been repeatedly shown to restrict inventory, the exact opposite of what we need to occur, and the bill is expensive – costs not only for the landlords, but also the DSHA and staff needed to comply, monitor and enforce the regulations.  A related bill would permit tenant who is in default of payment of rent to remain in the unit if the tenant pays all due at any time before the actual execution of the eviction order. There is no provision for recovery of costs to the landlord who has to bring the action.  Both these bills will have a chilling effect on the willingness of the many, smaller landlords who do not have a large number of units and who make a little extra money renting.

Finally, there is a bad idea on the horizon. If you do not like what Venice Beach and San Francisco look like today, you need to oppose HB 135, or you are potentially looking at Delaware tomorrow.  HB 135, and I quote directly from the synopsis, “permits an individual experiencing homelessness to conduct life sustaining activities in public, so long as such activities do not obstruct the normal movement of pedestrian or vehicular traffic in such a manner that creates a hazard to others, unless adequate alternative indoor space is available to the individual in a given jurisdiction and has been offered to the individual, including transportation for the individual and their belongings. 2. Mandates that an individual experiencing homelessness receive the same degree of protection for personal property stored in public places as personal property stored in a private dwelling, which includes protections against unreasonable search and seizure. 3. Prohibits the State or local jurisdiction from requiring an individual experiencing homelessness to move a motor vehicle or a recreational vehicle provided that the vehicle is parked on public property and the vehicle is not parked in a position to obstruct the normal movement of traffic or create a hazard for other traffic upon the highway. 4. Provides that, if a motor vehicle or recreational vehicle must be moved because the vehicle is obstructing normal movement of traffic or creates a hazard to other traffic on the roadway, the individual experiencing homelessness must be permitted to relocate the vehicle before a parking ticket is issued, or the vehicle is towed.”

This is not the best use of resources for those who find themselves homeless – whether due to finances, mental health, substance abuse issues or abandonment. Endorsement of living on the street outside of our homes, stores and doctors’ offices should not be a government function.  And enforcement will be a nightmare. What if an individual is not with the vehicle that is obstructing normal movement when the traffic is piling up behind it? What if it is towed and then the officer discovers it was owned or occupied by a homeless person? What possible protection can property have, stored in public, that would be equivalent to the protection property stored under key or locked in a safe in a home? Whose obligation is it to assure that property is protected?

Delaware has some challenges meeting the demand for housing, there is no question. But reduced regulations can reduce building costs, reasonable rental provisions will encourage expanded supply, and laws providing incentives to diversify our inventory will meet more of the market demand.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

The Vision Coalition is Failing Delaware Students

By Tanya Hettler, Ph.D., Guest Contributor

Delaware is in the middle of a “literacy crisis” as both Delaware’s Governor Meyer and Education Secretary Marten have acknowledged. Despite this, the Vision Coalition–an influential group that has guided education policy for nearly two decades–continues to prioritize “student-centered learning” over proven, evidence-based instruction. As reading and math scores remain low across the state, it’s time to take a closer look at who is shaping Delaware’s education agenda—and what they are prioritizing.

According to the National Institute for Direct Instruction, Direct Instruction (DI) “emphasizes well-developed and carefully planned lessons designed around small learning increments and clearly defined and prescribed teaching tasks. It is based on the theory that clear instruction eliminating misinterpretations can greatly improve and accelerate learning.”

Research shows that DI is the most effective teaching model overall and is especially beneficial for at-risk students.

The Vision Coalition’s Influence

The Vision Coalition is an influential group in Delaware with a leadership team consisting of K-12 school and college leaders, representatives from private companies and nonprofits, school board members, the president of the Delaware teachers union, and government leaders including the Delaware Secretary.

Every 10 years the group produces a 10-year plan. The newly released plan is titled Student Equity and Excellence 2035 and contains a set of policy recommendations spread across six key issue areas–early care and education, student-centered learning, student support, postsecondary success, educators, and student-centered funding.

 A Misplaced Focus on Student-Centered Learning

At the heart of the plan is the Vision Coalition’s core tenet of “student-centered learning” which it defines as follows:

“Every student, beginning at birth, has a right to a comprehensive, equitable education personalized to their unique needs, strengths, and talents. Designed with the capacity to give space for each child’s interests, passions, dreams, skills, and needs, education centers and empowers them as active participants in their learning.”

This sounds ideal–but in practice, it fails the very students it claims to help. As Houston Independent School District’s Superintendent Mike Miles, who is working to turn around one of the nation’s largest underperforming districts, has said the problem with ‘student-centric’ learning is that “students cannot guide their own learning when they cannot read” nor can they “just do what they’re interested in when they’re way behind in math.”

Delaware’s Science of Reading Mandates

In contrast, Delaware law has taken an important step toward evidence-based reform. The state legislature has passed four laws (SB 133, SS 1 for SB 4, HB 304, and SS 1 for SB 252) that require the implementation of the Science of Reading in K-12 schools.

According to the Delaware Department of Education:

“The State of Delaware defines the Science of Reading as a vast, interdisciplinary body of scientifically-based research about reading and issues related to reading and writing. For full definition see The Reading League.” (sic, emphasis in original)

The Reading League’s Science of Reading Defining Guide adds:

“This research has been conducted over the last five decades across the world, and it is derived from thousands of studies conducted in multiple languages. The science of reading has culminated in a preponderance of evidence to inform how proficient reading and writing develop; why some have difficulty; and how we can most effectively assess and teach and, therefore, improve student outcomes through prevention of and intervention for reading difficulties.”

In essence, the “Science of Reading” supports direct and explicit literacy instruction–a model that runs counter to the Vision Coalition’s emphasis on individualized, student-led approaches.

The Vision Coalition’s North Star: Missing the Mark

The Vision Coalition’s plan includes a guiding vision–its “North Star”–which focuses on critical thinking, wellbeing, communication, self-determination and community commitment.

Figure 1: The Vision Coalition’s “North Star”

Notably, the North Star omits core academic knowledge. The plan mentions it only in passing, stating it should “complement the durable, foundational skills that employers need most.”

The framework reverses the proper order. Core academic knowledge is the foundation on which skills like communication and critical thinking must be built.

Research has found that it does not work to teach topics such as critical thinking or communication without first equipping students with factual knowledge to think or communicate about.

Even more concerning, the plan does not prioritize literacy, despite existing state mandates and widespread acknowledgement of Delaware’s reading crisis.

A Literacy Crisis Worsens

When both the governor and education secretary have stated that Delaware is in the middle of a “literacy crisis,” it is troubling that the state’s most influential education coalition is not aligning its goals with improving reading outcomes. Instead, the Vision Coalition continues to promote its student-centered learning model, ignoring the direction set by Delaware law.

According to the coalition’s website, more than 75% of its policy recommendations have been advanced. Given the current academic outcomes, that track record should raise serious concerns.

Put Literacy First

Despite two decades of influence, none of the coalition’s stated goals directly address literacy or mathematics. Today, only 41% of Delaware students can read proficiently and only 31% can do math at grade level. In fact, the number of students able to read or do math at grade level has declined significantly over the 20-year period of the Vision Coalition’s existence.

As the Caesar Rodney Institute has documented, the Science of Reading–direct, explicit instruction based on decades of evidence–is the most effective path to improving literacy outcomes. Delaware’s students deserve an effective education, especially for the neediest students–not one that simply makes equity one of its talking points.

Tanya Hettler, Ph.D. is the Director of the Center for Education Policy at the Ceasar Rodney Institute.