/* */ /* Mailchimp integration */
-1
archive,paged,author,author-zoe,author-2,paged-10,author-paged-10,wp-theme-stockholm,wp-child-theme-stockholm-child,stockholm-core-1.0.8,select-child-theme-ver-1.1,select-theme-ver-5.1.5,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,menu-animation-underline,header_top_hide_on_mobile,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-6.0.2,vc_responsive

A Disconnect in Delaware’s Healthcare: A Call for Reform

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

If you open up the 2024 Senior Healthcare State Report Card on the SeniorLiving.org website, the first key finding shows that Delaware gets an ‘F’ grade. The report looks at three key factors affecting senior citizens, who, while suffering declining health and often on fixed incomes or Medicare coverage, have difficulty in navigating and accessing the healthcare they need.  Those factors are cost, access to care and quality of care.

In fact, the report ranked Delaware 49th among the states and the District of Columbia. Sadly, the report noted that Delaware was the only state to rank 40th or worse in all three categories.  Drug costs are notably high, in fact, 39% higher than the national average.  And the report found that we have the worst stroke death rate in the nation.

Why is this important in the big picture in Delaware? Because we have a rapidly aging population, growing at a rate faster than the rest of the nation, and are the fifth “oldest” state in the nation.  How we deliver, and how well we deliver, health care to seniors is important.

You might wonder then, why US News and World Report just ranked Delaware second in the nation for hospital quality. It is in the delivery of care.  The inefficient use of our resources has resulted in poor health outcomes for Delawareans.

And it is not just seniors who suffer – we all do.  The average wait time in an emergency room is over 3 hours, 6th worst in the nation.  And a recent report by the Delaware Department of Health and Social Services made clear that benchmarks related to cancer screening, opioid deaths, the use of statins for heart health and other preventative care were not met.  Indeed, the director of health care reform for the Delaware Department of Health and Social Services acknowledged there is a “disconnect” between spending and the quality of health outcomes. So, what can we do?

Sadly, we need to look no farther than our own public policies to see how to improve cost, access and quality. Delaware is one of a shrinking number of states that still retains an archaic law requiring a “certificate of need.” That law requires any entity or company that wants to either establish or expand their facilities, acquire a new technology or offer new services to get permission from a government panel, on which other health care providers serve.  As one person put it, imagine Burger King having to ask permission to build a restaurant and McDonald’s sitting on the committee that will decide.  That is precisely what the certificate of need law does. It allows current providers to decide how much competition they will have.  Studies, including those done by the Institute for Justice, consistently show that states with certificate of need laws have higher costs and inferior access to care and health outcomes.

Delaware’s legislature has recognized we are spending more, but the steps they have taken to try to reduce that spending are flawed. Most recently, they established a government appointed panel to review hospitals’ budgets and gave the panel the authority to override spending decisions by the hospital.  We have written before about how ill-advised this law is – it will discourage new providers and companies from coming to Delaware, and the only model for the idea is floundering and likely near failure in Vermont.

But talk about disconnect – at the same hearing at which the legislators approved the funds for the panel, they voted to expand the services which were covered by the state and eliminate co-pay fees for those services.  We need to be smarter about how we spend our money and that doesn’t include installing a government supervisory committee over hospital budgets. Competition will bring down prices. New York and California, which have no certificate of need laws and more open competition, have multiple hospital providers and they have better results for their citizens, Delaware citizens would be better served if we adopted policies that allow the ingenuity, creativity, experience and expertise of those who provide medical care the opportunity to fully offer those services, without impediment or government interference.

Finally, more transparency in the pricing of health care services would help patients make better and more appropriate decisions about where to get care.  We do have laws that require information to be made available, but they are not uniformly followed, and there is no enforcement.

There is some good news. To give credit, the walk-in centers, now associated with our hospital systems, have made a big difference in the overuse and drain on emergency room staff. As reported, we have emergency room wait times of over 3 hours. But that is down from nearly 6 hours and 2nd worst in the nation a few years ago.

And, we have information. The benchmark report on the quality of health care and health outcomes is an open book that lets us know what our objectives are, and where we are getting better, or not, in meeting those objectives. And we have an honest broker in

Jazette Manning, Secretary of the Department of Health and Social Services. In discussing the benchmark report, she acknowledged that there is still significant work to be done to improve healthcare outcomes of Delawareans.

Every state agency leader should establish and publish goals for their agency, and regularly report on their progress or lack thereof, whatever the facts reflect. With specific goals, focused effort and public scrutiny, our government will work better for us – the citizens who fund it and who it is to serve.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

Delaware Climate Legislation:2024 Edition

By: Dr. David R. Legates, Guest Contributor

In August 2023, the General Assembly passed, and the Governor signed Delaware’s Climate Change Solutions Act of 2023, or HB99.  It calls for the state to establish targets “to mitigate the adverse effects of climate change anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions on the State.”  Moreover, it also establishes “Climate Change Officers in certain Key Cabinet-Level Departments who will assist DNREC in the ongoing implementation of the Climate Action Plan.”  Note that the bill charges the DNREC Secretary and other entities within the Executive Branch with making climate change an integral part of decision-making, rulemaking, and procurement—the legislature abdicated their responsibility to oversee its implementation to the Executive Branch.

This year, the General Assembly passed five more bills, supposedly to save the State from the ravages of climate change.  As before, climate change is only the stated goal; it is not the real focus of the legislation.

The Delaware Energy Solutions Act of 2024, also known as Senate Bill 265, supports the net zero goals of HB99 by facilitating “offshore wind to be a significant element of Delaware’s energy future.”  Through this legislation, the General Assembly has passed the authority of making decisions regarding offshore wind to the State Energy Office and the Public Service Commission.

House Bill 9 requires that all state-owned passenger and light duty vehicles be zero emission vehicles by 2040, although exemptions are made for law enforcement vehicles and “vessels of State agency law-enforcement personnel,” vehicles owned by the Department of Education, school districts, and charter schools, and designated take home vehicles for certain state employees.  Similarly, House Substitute 2 for House Bill 13 authorizes a program, headed by the Director of the Sustainable Energy Utility, to assist low-income residents to purchase and install electric vehicles and their recharging systems.

Two additional bills focus on longer-range planning.  House Bill 402 requires that all new state buildings, including schools, to provide a designated space on the roof reserved for future solar panel installation.  And Senate Bill 237 ensures future plans focus on community resiliency and sustainability as it relates to impacts of climate change.

These bills serve to move Delaware toward an economy free of fossil fuel-based energy sources.  Offshore wind and rooftop solar will necessarily make energy more expensive, as will proliferation of plans to protect our communities and prepare public buildings from the non-issue of dangerous climate change.  By every metric available, our very existence is NOT being threatened by increasing storms, floods, droughts, hurricanes, tornadoes, and sea level rise.

In 2021, Delaware’s energy use was only 0.264% of the total energy use in the United States.  Requiring the United States to become Net Zero by 2050 will save the planet from a rise of only 0.06°F by 2050.  Thus, Delaware’s legislation to force the State into Net Zero compliance will lead to a decrease of only 0.00016°F—a number that is unmeasurable with any environmental thermometer in use.  It will have no effect whatsoever on the impact of storms, floods, droughts, sea level rise, and other weather variables that impact people’s lives and affect their possessions.  What will happen is that energy and all goods that use energy for production, transportation, or refrigeration will become much more expensive.

One only has to consider the question of why these legislative bills make exceptions for law enforcement, state-owned school buses, and selective state agencies and why subsidies are needed for low-income residents of the state.  As before, these legislations are not about the science—it’s about making energy so expensive few will be able to afford it.

Dr. David R. Legates is an Emeritus Professor at the University of Delaware and is the Director of Research and Education at the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation.  He also is an Advisory Board Member of A Better Delaware.

Demanding Transparency: Why Delaware Needs to Hold Its Government Accountable

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

We at A Better Delaware have long contended that more transparency is needed in Delaware’s government.  Information about what our elected officials are doing in their official roles and with our tax dollars should be readily available. Sadly, that is not the case. According to the Pioneer Institute, Delaware ranks among the six worst states for financial transparency.

We certainly saw evidence of a lack of transparency recently with the revelation, months later, that there had been a criminal embezzlement of public funds at the Department of Labor Unemployment office. Think of the complicity that such a deception required – co-workers of the individual who committed the crime, the individuals who investigated the matter within the agency, the police investigators, perhaps even the highest levels of our State government.  Yet they felt no obligation to report the incident publicly. And this is not a partisan issue – both Democrats and Republicans raised concerns, former Democrat legislator John Kowalko among the most vocal.

What if you want to know how well your student’s school is doing with promoting actual learning? Well, according to an expert in these matters, it takes six different “clicks” on the Department of Education website to get to the information. A bill that would have required that to be available from the Department’s Home Page failed in the General Assembly last year.

Did you know that while we have no sales tax in Delaware, we have a gross receipts tax, and that vendors, stores and companies are not allowed to display that tax as an addition to the cost of an item or service you purchase? Tax free shopping? Or invisible tax shopping? Delaware is one of only a few states that retain that tax in their funding structure.

Remember the heavy-handed, boulder-sized response the Governor and General Assembly had last session to address the state’s health care costs? They established a 5-person government appointed panel to review hospital budgets with the authority to reject a hospital’s proposed spending plans or to demand specific expenditures.  (Hospitals are now suing over that legislation.) Did you know that, at the same appropriations hearing at which the General Assembly authorized $700,000 to administer that oversight program, they also authorized expanded health care coverage and eliminated co-apays for state employees and retirees for certain medical procedures? And they wonder why the state’s health care costs are so high!

Why is transparency so important? Without transparency, there is no accountability.  If you don’t know how poorly your student’s school is performing, you won’t be at the school board hearing demanding better. If you don’t know there was embezzlement, you won’t demand better and more effective accounting systems. If you don’t know that the state is crying “wolf” on the one hand, and increasing costs on the other, you won’t ask them “Why?” If you aren’t aware of all the ways the government is getting its tax money, you won’t appreciate that it is not the business that is increasing prices to gouge you but raising them to cover the hidden costs of doing business in the state.

The Center for Public Integrity gives Delaware an “F.” Specific measures include State Budget Processes (42nd), Internal Auditing (43rd) Legislative Accountability (48th) and Ethics Enforcement (43rd).

Delaware needs to be more transparent, and our state officials need to be held accountable.  An Inspector General can assure an independent review of agency actions, and more transparency.  An ethics officer can assure better scrutiny of the conduct of state officials.  Delaware should pass laws to create both offices now. The citizens of our state deserve to know when, how and why our government is acting, and where our money is being spent.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

 

 

A Guide to the General Election: Stay Informed and Vote!

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

The primary election is over, and the candidate slate for the general election to be held in November has been set.

We at A Better Delaware feel it is important for voters to be informed about where the candidates stand on the issues that are important to them.  Over the next several weeks, we are going to present information from materials prepared by the candidates, either electronically or printed, that express their positions on the core issues of education, energy, and the economy.

A Better Delaware will not be endorsing any specific candidate or telling you for which one you should vote. What we want to do to educate you about the candidates’ positions on the issues that we cover on a regular basis in order to help you make your decision about how to vote.  There will be links to the candidates’ websites so you can further explore those, and other, issues on your own.

Only 22% of eligible voters came to the polls on primary day. It’s a shame that more people don’t exercise the authority they have to determine who will govern them. Imagine it this way- your bothersome next-door neighbor that you don’t care much for and disagree with on everything could decide your future simply by pushing a couple of buttons. Sound appealing? Of course not.

Go to the polls and vote for the people you think will make your life better, improve your state and community and reflect your views as they conduct the government’s business.

There are a number of offices we will cover. The statewide offices – Governor, Lt. Governor, Insurance Commissioner, US House of Representatives, and US Senate.  We will also select a few local races we deem competitive, such as state legislature and perhaps even some county races.

This year is a presidential election year and voter turnout is usually higher for the general election in a presidential election year, but it’s a shame so few people engage in our election process.  So be committed to becoming informed and show up at the polls. Bring some friends with you and share the information you learn from our newsletters freely, with friends and your neighbors (except you know who!).

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

The Crisis in Education Requires Our Attention

By: Nancy Mercante, Guest Contributor

Our moral obligation to the children is clear: we must nurture and educate them well. It’s time to apply this commitment to all children by fixing the failures of our public education system.

All children have a right to get a good education. It requires close teamwork among parents, teachers and students. Parents are solely responsible for the education and upbringing of their children in four areas: spiritual, moral, health and academic motivation. Teachers provide students with instruction in reading, writing, math, and critical thinking that enables children to achieve their full potential as productive members of society. Together, parents and educators should teach young people how to become good citizens who can think for themselves and make morally and socially wise decisions.

 Too many children who attend K-12 public schools in Delaware enter adulthood unprepared to lead successful lives. For decades Delaware public schools have failed to provide all children with an adequate education in a safe, caring environment supported by involved parents.

Many factors contribute to this sad situation. The most obvious one is the crowding out of emphasis on the basics: reading, writing and math. Leading causes are inefficient bureaucracy, ideological interference, and the influence of social media, both in and out of the classroom. We rely too much on teachers to manage and resolve long-standing social issues from within the classroom, limiting their time and ability to teach core subject matter in a controlled and predictable environment.

Despite spending an average of $20,000 per student in 2023 according to the Delaware Department of Education, children are promoted through the system without achieving grade level proficiency in the basic knowledge needed to prosper in life.

While Delaware spending on public schools is near the top in the nation, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) ranks Delaware students near the bottom in ability to master core subjects:

  • 47th in fourth grade reading
  • 48th in sixth grade reading
  • 45th in eighth grade math and reading

This means that about seven of ten Delaware public school students graduate without the skills they need in these core subjects.

For minority students, it’s much worse. In at least 17 schools with mostly minority students, fewer than one in ten students can read or do math at grade level. Research tells us that if children can’t read at grade level by third grade, they rarely recover. Instead, they get trapped in a system where they never catch up. This gives rise to a lifetime of underperformance that often leads to poverty, crime, drugs and even prison.

In short, the decline in Delaware’s public education system is devastating for these students, our communities and our state.

Public pressure could bring more change, but our voices aren’t loud enough yet. The general apathy about this situation is shocking. Many parents may think their kids are doing well because they get passing grades at school. Some parents are too busy working two jobs to make ends meet. Many others may simply lack the motivation or knowledge to help their own children.

Many parents are unaware that public-school districts actively promote ideologies that conflict with and undermine their own moral values.  Parents, citizens and organizations must unite to constantly reinforce the power of faith and the principles of hard work, resilience, and integrity upon which our nation was founded.

Whatever the reason for such apathy, we must change it and recognize the moral imperative to educate all children. Nothing will get better until parents and the public at large become aware of the true state of public education in Delaware and demand better. You can contribute immensely by leading an effort to promote a CAMPAIGN OF AWARENESS as a starting point to motivate people to act. We must accept responsibility for the education of all children.

Now is the time to commit to improving education to put all children within reach of the potential each and every one of them has been given.

Nancy Mercante had a career in corporate communications for major companies in the financial, pharmaceutical and telecommunications industries. She founded Citizens for Delaware Schools, a nonpartisan nonprofit, two years ago to advocate for a better education for every student in Delaware.

 

Pathways to Success: Careers in Delaware’s Construction Industry

By: Guest Contributor, Edward Capodanno, President, Associated Builders and Contractors, Delaware

Associated Builders and Contractors, Delaware Chapter is an organization that represents the Construction Industry – a lifeblood of Delaware’s economy and one that for years has driven economic growth in the state and nationally. The industry provides a direct pathway to personal prosperity and the ability to earn a high-quality living without the burden of excessive college debt.

This is a message our association and our members try to communicate daily.  We feel that, when effectively communicated, it inspires individuals and their families to be even more focused on their opportunities for future success.

Nationally, the average age of a construction worker is 47 and for every five people leaving our industry, just one is entering.  At this rate, and over the next three years, the shortage of new workers could stall Delaware’s economic engine that is now restarting.

As an improving economy, supported a renewed focus on thoughtful economic development creates new opportunities in Delaware, the need for well-trained, certified, skilled workers become more important.

The opportunities that are available to new workers entering the industry is immense.  The following careers and numbers shown below are average annual salaries and do not include overtime, company incentives or benefits:

Boilermakers – $58,856

Carpenter – $54,157

Electrician – $57,741

Heavy Equipment Operator – $61,091

HVAC Technician- $42,026

Plumber – $51,830

Mason – $54,860

Pipefitter – $59,558

All of these opportunities and more are available to Delawareans who are willing to make a career commitment to the industry. This is truly a pathway to a good life and the opportunity to begin a career without the burden of debt.

A quick look at industry statistics, updated quarterly, shows that in Delaware alone there are over 10,000 positions awaiting workers representing more than 20 skilled trades. While antiquated regulations and land use restrictions are factors in the shortage of affordable housing in Delaware, this lack of capable and skilled trades workers has more of an impact than other causes. And, as the crisis grows, affordable housing is an issue that is getting more attention by policymakers.

ABC Delaware stands committed to developing the construction workforce of tomorrow.  In fact, we, along with a broader group of interested leaders, are meeting regularly with Delaware educational leadership to help shape a new direction, redefine curriculum, and build a digital campaign designed to help Delaware students and their parents better understand the multitude of opportunities provided by the construction industry.

Edward J. Capodanno has served as President of Associated Builders and Contractors, Delaware Chapter and the Construction Education Foundation of Delaware since 1993. Ed also serves on a number of governmental task forces, including the Delaware Workforce Investment Board, and Governor’s Workers’ Compensation Oversight Panel. He previously served on the Governor’s Procurement Council, the Governor’s Prevailing Wage task force, the Department of Education School Construction Committee, Delaware Blue Collar Jobs task force and the New Castle County Vocational School District mentoring program. He has received numerous community and civic awards and recognition for his service.

 

 

Unlocking Delaware’s Potential: The Case for Tax Reform

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

The Governor recently signed a number of bills passed by the Delaware General Assembly to help, in their view, with increasing the rate of home ownership in our state. Included in the package were an incentive program to create and expand workforce housing, elimination of the expiration of the mortgage mediation and foreclosure prevention programs and excuse from certain, limited purchases from a particular state transfer tax for contractors.  General home buyers and sellers are still required to pay the most expensive realty transfer tax in the nation, however, 4%. That means that for every hundred dollars you pay for a home, $4 is taken for the transfer tax. While it is often split between seller and buyer, as negotiated, that translates to a tax of $12,000 for a house costing $300,000.  We would have been well served if the General Assembly had reduced that tax. It stifles the economy. It discourages people who would like to relocate or seniors who would like to downsize, from doing so, as they are required to pay twice – once to sell, and then again to buy.

But transfer taxes are not the only way government reaching into the till is affecting Delaware.

We have written here on many occasions that our General Assembly should repeal our gross receipts tax. Perhaps some explanation of why we are so adamant would be helpful. Gross receipts taxes are an archaic idea that started, according to reports, in the 13th century.  Delaware remains one of only seven states to retain a state gross receipts tax.  Most states have abandoned them for good reason. These taxes are on the money businesses receive from sales, before accounting for any of their costs for staff, materials, rent and other business expenses. They take money away that might be spent on expanding a business or adding a new product or service. For businesses with narrow profit margins, such as the mom-and-pop stores, or the new entrepreneur, it can eliminate most or in some instances, all of the profit, even jeopardizing the owners’ own compensation.  And, of course, these taxes add to the costs of products and services to you, the customer.  Delaware should repeal the gross receipts tax.

Delaware has seen an outmigration of talent over many years now. Bringing new business and keeping businesses that provide high paying, technical and manufacturing jobs should be a priority. It has not been. Whether in the bioscience area, the manufacture of alternative energy source components or chip and computer manufacturing and development, we should expand options in Delaware. We need to keep our citizens with skilled and bright young minds here in Delaware and attract new and competitive skilled workers to our state.  Corporate income taxes impact our ability to do so.  Research continuously shows that taxes are a factor in a state’s ability to attract and keep business.  Our corporate tax rate is one of the highest in the country (we are ranked No. 7 by the Tax Foundation).  Studies demonstrate that high taxes reduce investment in new and improved technology, impact efficiency, and result in lower wages, or fewer increases in wages, for employees. Freedom from a high tax burden allows businesses the freedom to grow, innovate and thrive.  We should reduce our corporate tax rate.

The American Legislative Exchange Council ranks Delaware 30th of the states in economic outlook. Our tax rates are a component of that rating. Lack of innovation and imagination of what Delaware could be, what opportunities we could offer, what exciting challenges we could give to the talent and skill we have right now in our schools and universities, is holding us back.  Let’s unleash that talent and turn potential into production.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

.

Why Does the State Energy Plan Sound So Familiar?

By: Dr. David R. Legates, Advisory Board Member, A Better Delaware

Recently, the State’s new five-year energy plan has been made available for a second round of feedback. A new energy plan is due this year; after all, it has been five years since the last one was implemented.

Five-year plans will sound familiar to those of you that remember the old Soviet “five-year plans for the development of the national economy of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.”  Other communist nations such as the People’s Republic of China also adopted five-year plans.

The proposed five-year plan for the development of the state economy of Delaware focuses heavily on a transition to so-called renewable energy.  This requirement was legislated by HB99 through its goal of achieving zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.  The five-year plan also establishes an offshore wind procurement program to facilitate this net-zero transition.  This plan will extend through 2029, just in time to see the state achieve its preliminary goal of reducing its greenhouse gas emissions by one-half by 2030.

While the plan calls for a myriad of things to address climate change, none of them are new concepts.  For example, the plan pushes for getting the public to adopt electric vehicles and to restrict the purchase of vehicles that run on fossil fuels.  Transportation is the largest sector that uses energy (more than one-third) and thus converting transportation to batteries is essential to meeting the 2030 goal set by HB99.

Moreover, this transition will necessarily reduce funds to the state arising from motor fuel taxes.  Consequently, the state’s five-year plan calls for the development of a revised fee structure to extract taxes from owners of zero-emission vehicles.  After all, state revenue cannot be sacrificed at the altar of green energy.

Other objectives established by the five-year plan include the transition to biodiesel and other sources of energy that will limit our food supply and make it even more expensive to feed our families.  Taxpayer funds also will be earmarked to facilitate the transition to so-called renewable energy sources.  After all, this transition will not come cheaply.

The plan also puts environmental justice and energy equity front and center.  Note that wind and solar are neither ‘clean’ nor ‘green’ as the mining and production of the components required to manufacture the wind turbines, solar panels, and batteries necessary to facilitate this transition is associated with child exploitation, slavery, land destruction, and the creation of toxic lakes.  Consequently, the transition to wind and solar energy necessarily harms people and children in developing and under-developed countries.  If one is truly concerned about environmental justice, why does the plan favor energy sources that harm poor countries through the creation of hazardous waste, the extraction of the requisite rare-earth minerals, and degradation of land uses from which they, and especially their children, clearly do not benefit?

Of course, the plan will achieve energy equity by making energy so expensive, few will be able to afford it.  The legislature set this process in motion and the administration, through DNREC, are all too willing to implement it.  This plan must be derailed if Delaware is to remain a great place to live.

Dr. David R. Legates is an Emeritus Professor at the University of Delaware and is the Director of Research and Education at the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation.  He also is an Advisory Board Member of A Better Delaware.

The True Price of Delaware’s Tax Policies: Impact on Residents and Businesses

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

 This is the next in a series of articles that will take a look at how the policy principles and legislative priorities of A Better Delaware fared in the last legislative session, which ended on June 30.  We have written over several years now about our perspective on healthcare, education, energy, the economy and workforce in Delaware, as well as the need for more accountability and better transparency in the way government works in Delaware. 

In this series, we will look at how the action the legislature took promotes or inhibits achievement of those policy objectives we feel are important to make Delaware a better place for families, workers, businesses and the community at large.

Fiscal and Tax Policy

Many Delawareans are feeling the pinch in their pocketbook. “Luxuries”, like dining out, are falling by the wayside as people struggle to find the money to buy necessities.  Many of you might blame inflation, and that is certainly a significant reason, but in Delaware, it is also our taxes, and the burden our state’s tax policy puts on individuals and businesses.

The American Legislative and Exchange Council (ALRC) conducted a review to evaluate the tax burden on individuals and businesses in all 50 states. Delaware ranked #1, of course, when it came to sales taxes, because we don’t have one. And we did fairly well with regard to the property tax burden (we will have to wait to see how we fare after assessment, which is now occurring pursuant to court order).  Our top personal income tax and corporate income tax rates were ranked at 47, so, high as compared to other states.  But the real kicker? We ranked 50th, yes, last (worst) for “remaining tax burden”. What is “remaining tax burden”?  Mostly state and Local taxes.  That could mean the tax you pay to transfer title to your car, boat or mobile home, property transfer taxes, gross receipts taxes, and the many other hidden taxes you pay to do business with the state or local government.

Many states have acted to relieve their citizens of tax burdens. Since the pandemic, more than 30 states have enacted reductions in their individual income tax rates, six of them just this year. Others have reduced their franchise taxes or capped property taxes.  We have argued that Delaware needs to reduce or eliminate property transfer taxes, gross receipts taxes and personal and corporate income taxes – taxes that take real money from hardworking moms, pops and students in our state. Sadly, Delaware’s General Assembly and Governor have failed to act, and despite our reputation as a tax-free state, we are anything but.  These reforms remain among our priorities.

Why should the high corporate tax rates or the gross receipts tax matter to you, an individual taxpayer in Delaware? Well, the gross receipts tax makes everything cost more – nearly everything you buy. It is a tax on the total the owner of the business takes in, and then, when they make money after expenses, the amount they take home from their business is taxed again. So, it is, literally, a sales tax by another name.

As for the corporate tax rates, the market is much more competitive today than it used to be, to attract businesses to incorporate and do business in a state.  Tax rates are a significant consideration in making that decision.  Delaware receives more than $1 billion each year from businesses that choose to incorporate here, reflecting filing fees, formation fees and franchise taxes.  The loss of that income would present a difficult challenge to those managing our state budget.  We are ranked just three states from the bottom on this metric. The legislature and Governor should act to reduce these taxes.

But taxes aren’t the only factor that can discourage companies from locating in Delaware.  The legal climate can be a factor as well. In this regard, the legislature enacted two bills that will affect corporate decision making.

The first established a government appointed panel that will oversee the finances and decision making of private and non-profit businesses.  The immediate focus was on hospitals and the intent was to reduce the amount the state pays for healthcare for its employees and retirees.  Based on comments from legislators, that is only the first category of businesses and non-profits to be targeted. We have previously opined that this step could further reduce the desirability of incorporating in Delaware and jeopardize our revenue stream.  An update on that legislation: although the hospitals negotiated some changes and stood back as the bill passed, Christiana Care has now filed to have the bill invalidated.  We will keep our readers informed as that case progresses.

The second is a bill that changes the extent to which restrictions may be placed on the decision-making of a corporate board of directors by a shareholder without a vote of the other shareholders. The bill was in response to a decision of the Court of Chancery upholding a challenge by a minority shareholder to specific veto and approval authority a shareholder/founder wanted to retain and reverses the Court’s ruling.  While the impact remains to be seen, that is precisely the issue. Our legal climate, always held to be the best in providing certainty for business ventures, is now being challenged by an activist General Assembly. That, coupled with the response by at least one high profile business (think Elon Musk) to relocate from Delaware, also in response to a court decision, could lead to hesitancy by other businesses to incorporate here. Again, we will monitor the legal landscape and bring updates as appropriate to our readers.

You may be aware that the Unemployment Insurance Fund recently reported that significant funds were embezzled and that the systems used in processing claims were so corrupted that a proper audit of the agency’s handling of funds could not be completed.  This session, the legislature did two things to help begin improvements at that agency.  First, they approved a change in the “benefits wage ratio methodology” that will ease determinations of benefits.  Second, they authorized a recurring and ongoing review of criminal arrests by staff with both the state and federal law enforcement databases. Previously a criminal background check was done only at hiring.  Such a system would have alerted the agency that the staff member allegedly involved in the embezzlement was arrested for theft outside of work while employed there.  Remarkably, the legislation does not apply to all state agencies.  It should.  A previous situation involving Delaware State University’s police department revealed that several members had adverse law enforcement contact while employed there. While that situation was resolved internally and by policy, every state agency should ensure all staff are in compliance with criminal laws.

In sum, the actions by the General Assembly have an impact on our economy. They should consider the big picture, enact laws that ensure continued dominance in the corporate world, create economic incentives for businesses to locate here and implement tax structures for them to thrive here. They should relieve our citizens of their tax burden.  And they should always remember whose money it is that they are spending – yours and mine!

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.

 

 

 

Beyond the Budget: Seeking Solutions in Delaware’s Education System

By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware

 This is the third in a series of articles that will take a look at how the policy principles and legislative priorities of A Better Delaware fared in the last legislative session, which ended on June 30.  We have written over several years now about our perspective on healthcare, education, energy, the economy and workforce in Delaware, as well as the need for more accountability and better transparency in the way government works in Delaware. 

In this series, we will look at how the action the legislature took promotes or inhibits achievement of those policy objectives we feel are important to make Delaware a better place for families, workers, businesses and the community at large.

Education Policy

You may already know all the numbers. Delaware is in the top ten in spending on education, and the bottom five in student performance.  We have over a dozen schools with single digit proficiencies in math and reading, most of them minority majority.  Delaware spends over $20,000 per student per year, according to the latest figures from the Department of Education.  There has been an inverse correlation between increases in spending and lower achievement scores – as spending has gone up, performance has gone down.  The Governor just recommended, and the General Assembly passed, a budget that increases spending in education significantly, and includes $3 million for “literacy specialists,” who will teach teachers how to teach reading.

So, what is the good news? Well, there really is a science to teaching reading, and many new teachers were never taught how to teach it the way you probably learned – phonics is the key.  So, we commend the attention to reading. After all, if you can’t read, you can’t learn.  But, once again, the Governor and legislature came up short. They did not provide specific goals for everyone – students, teachers and parents to reach – proficiency in reading at grade level by grade 3. That has proven to be the “secret” to success in Mississippi, a state that performed miserably for decades, but instituted a law that students cannot earn that moniker “4th grader” until they can read at a third-grade level. Mississippi, 6 or so years later, bests us by a mile. We need to establish goals and consequences in order to make change.  Just “teaching children to read” has failed Delaware students for some time now.

We had the opportunity to address some of the issues and bring transparency to the failings of these schools in the last General Assembly session.  The bill, HB 192 was proffered to require these poorly performing schools to present both short- and long-term plans to improve student performance to the Department of Education, and for the Department to issue an annual report on improvement (or the lack thereof).  While it passed in the House last year, and successfully passed through both the House and Senate Education Committees with bipartisan support, it has now stalled in the Senate.  Fearing that the bill will be a step toward school choice, the majority refused to bring it to a vote.

How arrogant! Because the other good news is that there are schools in Delaware that are succeeding. They just, mostly, are not public schools. You may have read in our previous newsletters that we at A Better Delaware support school choice, to give the poor students who are assigned to these poorly performing schools by a government that does not seem to be able to get the job done, a choice.  Other jurisdictions which have tried a choice program, enabling students to attend a private or parochial school of their choice, have seen remarkable gains in student success. And, we have proposed ways to offer choice without taking money out of the public schools. Our current education system, bloated and ineffective, is consigning children who are required to attend poorly performing schools, solely by virtue of their zip code, to more difficult lives than any of them deserve.

We can improve education in Delaware, but it requires leadership that recognizes that more money is not the answer. Specific goals, consequences and rewards with respect to those goals, and more transparency and choice all will serve the children of Delaware better. Better job opportunities, better financial security and more personal satisfaction with their lives. The children of Delaware deserve that. The General Assembly should not stand in the way.

Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.