Affordable Housing Challenges and Regulatory Impacts in Delaware
By: Jane Brady, Chair, A Better Delaware
The Taxpayers Protection Alliance recently conducted a review of foreclosures on residential properties throughout the country. Delaware, sadly, has the fourth highest rate of those foreclosures. The experts who made that review determined that “zoning laws and land-use regulations significantly contribute to rising home prices” and cited restrictions on density (such as single-family-only zoning), building heights, lot sizes, and land-use types as factors that serve to limit the supply of land available for development of single-family homes.
It is certainly true that regulations affect construction of housing in Delaware. Recent events make that very clear. In 2009, the General Assembly passed a law requiring all new residential buildings to be zero net energy capable by the end of this year, 2025. Zero net energy is reached when a building is constructed to produce as much renewable energy as it consumes over a year, often through intense insulation, energy systems such as heat pumps, air quality monitoring and on-site renewable energy generation, such as with solar panels.
To comply with the statute, the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control prepared regulations to implement the intent of the General Assembly. They proposed one of the most aggressive energy codes in the country, which was set to take effect on December 31, 2025.
The Homebuilder Association and other advocacy organizations opposed the added requirements and unrealistic timeline. There is a housing affordability crisis in Delaware, and the new, expensive requirements are certain to affect both the business in construction and real estate sectors but also will add costs and time to the provision of housing to Delaware consumers, causing further harm.
Fortunately, this time, the concerns were heard and appreciated. Last week, Gregory Patterson, Secretary of the Delaware Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Control announced he would decline approval of the Department’s own proposal on the energy code. As he stated, “implementing ambitious new energy standards with mere weeks of lead time is not realistic.” Further, he noted that there had not been adequate analysis of the proposed regulations or sufficient consideration of the significant increase in the costs of compliance with the regulations.
That is good news for anyone in Delaware hoping to buy a home. But, not only for those hoping to buy – those who rent face challenges as well, and the increased costs would have been passed on by the owners of the rental units to the tenants.
In an effort to address the shortage of affordable housing, the various state and local agencies which provide access to rental accommodations have joined together to create a statewide waiting list of people looking for housing. Remarkably, there are over 20,000 people on the list, according to Matthew Heckles, Director of the Delaware State Housing Authority.
The situation with the proposed regulatory mandates for housing construction highlights another aspect of Delaware government, the significance of which many are not aware. State agencies are regularly given the authority by the General Assembly to create regulations to implement the laws the legislature passes. That includes the Department of Education, Natural Resources, and Labor, as well as the many other agencies in Delaware’s government. There are rules that provide for public notice and publication, opportunity for public comment, sometimes for a public hearing as well before the regulation can be adopted. These regulations can have significant impact on consumers, businesses and families in our state.
There is a place where you can go to see what new regulations are proposed. Each month, on the first of the month, the Registrar of Regulations is published. It can be accessed at regulations.delaware.gov In addition to the compilation of the proposed changes in regulations each month, that link will also take you to the Delaware Administrative Code, which reflects all the regulations currently in effect in Delaware. There is also a historical accounting course available from July 1997 available. This is where the EV Mandate first made its formal appearance.
Many people keep on top of what the General Assembly is doing. From January to June, our legislators meet, hold hearings and vote on bills. But the real impact of that legislation may more acutely be felt in the regulations the agencies involved adopt to implement the law. And the implementation of regulations occurs year-round, not just during the legislative session. It is important that you are aware of the way regulations are proposed and adopted, as they affect your everyday life.
We appreciate Secretary Patterson’s insight into the potentially terrible and unintended consequences that immediate implementation of the proposed regulations on zero net energy construction would have had. We look forward to a commonsense plan that keeps regulatory compliance costs low enough that a home is within reach for all Delawareans.
Jane Brady serves as Chair of A Better Delaware. She previously served as Attorney General of Delaware and as a Judge of the Delaware Superior Court.